ban appeal

eneka

Your SS14 Username: rotty

Banning Admin's Username: Pankeku

Role Ban or Server Ban: Server Ban

Round ID (if applicable): idk (3575?)

Reason for Ban: "[Intentional Mass Sabotage] [Unreasonable Inompetence in Role]
Experimented with the SM by purposely overclocking it and reaching 75 rads. This caused the radiation wave from the SM to reach to TWO departments which also caused 5 deaths with 2 of them being unrevivable due to the amount of radiation damage they had. You have also attempted this in the course of different rounds.

What lead up to the ban:
Me and Erisia attempted to reach the maximum amount of rads possible in a round, we started with getting our setup ready, and once it was done, we alerted the crew to not come close to engineering at all.
after it hit around 50 rads we shut it down immediately due to crew complaints,
(got arrested for being a possible ling, cooperated and gave sec my blood)
after this the CE arrived at the station, giving us the OK to continue testing.
and so we did after placing anti-radiation countermeasures.
we reached a peak of 75 rads and some must've leaked and killed 5, rr'ed 2.
after this we shutdown the engine, i turned myself in for indirect manslaughter of many people and logged off in perma.

Why you should be unbanned:

First, Unreasonable incompetence doesnt sit right with me because the CE gave us the ok to continue testing the SM
we also DID shutdown the engine everytime the radiation leak was too strong (keep in mind if you wish to see the replay of this round, we took extensive precautions and measures, made airlocks, placed plasma windows all over the engineering hallway, placed extra walls in the bar (weakspot) we even went to the point of adding geiger counters outside engineering to alert the crew incase of a radiation leak, we ALSO screamed in the radio MANY times to not come close to engineering, if my mind doesnt fail me, one of the RR'ed was a cadet stumbling around in ENGI maints. (ALSO keep in mind RR'ed people can be borged or EVEN cloned)

Second, Intentional Mass Sabotage, this one also confuses me because, we cant experiment with the SM anymore??, the ban reason states that i have attempted this in different rounds which is correct, i like playing around with the supermatter and i feel like we got banned for being too good at making one, not even once the SM came close to delamming.
We used ALL our tools possible to reinforce engineering hallways due to the known problem with radiation, however, this wasnt enough and it still killed people, (the SM in packed has MANY uranium windows with radiation shields)

an entire week for something that couldve been dealt IC is alot, i understand people got RR'ed but we tried to prevent this with the CE and we failed.

there is simply no kind of structure that shields from this amount of radiation (however icepick has recently pull requested uranium walls)

however at this specific round we worked with what we had and tried to prevent further death.

Icepick

Hi I'll be handling this appeal.

For a very long time, Advanced Engineering players have been causing issues where they push the mechanics of their department so far that it leads to damage to people and the station. Be it Atmospherics players making pipe setups that have the pressure of a black hole in it, or in this case, such a powerful radiation source that it kills people 2 departments over.

You and Erisia were the two main engineers that were running the Supermatter. By your own admission, issues began to arise around the 50 RADS point.

Despite telling people to "Not come to engineering" people still did, and they did die. In your own example you said a Cadet was Round Removed due to the high radiation. You cannot expect people to know or always remember to steer clear of a area because two engineers decided they wanted to make a new Fallout game out of the Engineering department.

After being down for a while, the Supermatter was turned on again because CE gave you the go ahead to do so. This is where you two should've realized that it may not be a good idea to push something that was causing issues even further because big number.

This is where the Intentional Station Sabotage comes in, you weren't forced to start the SM again, and were given the opportunity not to. However you two decided to continue, causing alot of damage to people and departments.

I will be accepting this appeal, however im not removing the ban. It will be shortened down to a day.

The actions that you and Erisia were doing had major side effects on the round, and ruined it for a decent chunk of the players. Experimenting on the Supermatter is allowed, but it has to be done with caution and reason. Very small amounts of that were present during that round.